Tag Archives: vibes

Bobby Hutcherson RIP

Vibraphone and Marimba maestro Bobby Hutcherson passed away in mid-August 2016, aged 75.

His New York Times obituary can be accessed here.

There’s an irreverent review of his Happenings set that I wrote a couple of years ago here.

London Jazz Collector has taken a look at Bobby Hutcherson’s records with recent reviews of several of his later releases.

RIP Bobby Hutcherson.


Happenings: Bobby Hutcherson


Bobby Hutcherson made a major contribution to one of my favourite tracks, Joe Henderson’s wonderful Mode For Joe. His vibes solo boosts a strong piece of music into the hyperspace of the outstanding.

This has encouraged me to buy a string of the vibraphonist’s recordings as leader in the hope that they might contain music that captivates me to the same extent. Unfortunately, I haven’t heard anything that hits the spot in the same way- but every so often I revisit Bobby’s albums to see if I’m missing something.

The root of my difficulty is partly that Hutcherson is probably a bit too complex and avant-garde in his repertoire for my taste. Then, there’s the timbre of the vibraphone, which can introduce a somewhat cool metallic quality to a piece- perhaps because playing the vibes involves banging a piece of metal. Still, I’ll persevere and a long solo Good Friday car journey offered another opportunity.

So another Good Friday without my favourite football team still offered up a contest- could Happenings compete with and defeat the sights of Birmingham, as seen from the M6? The Blue Note gang would be represented by the Crips and Bloods, Birmingham by the Peaky Blinders!

First up, Aquarian Moon, starting as a distant Birmingham skyline comes into sight on my approach from the south. The track has an air of expectancy and excitement and fits with my delight at reaching a significant landmark on a long slow journey. OK, so the Birmingham skyline palls by comparison to New York or even locally to Liverpool’s Three Graces but the tune holds its own. It’s still an early draw in the battle for my attention.

Bouquet is quiet and reflective but it is up against the architectural brutalism of Fort Dunlop. Midway through the first half and Birmingham strikes. One nil to the City of Birmingham!

Rojo has a bit of Latin life stirring and manages to see off Spaghetti Junction and Villa Park (despite a few good visits there to semi-finals back in the pre- New Wembley FA Cup days). Bobby, as fine a striker as you would expect a man with multiple mallets to be, has equalised and it is one all- with everything to play for. A YouTube clip follows:

Click or touch the arrow to play.

Maiden Voyage is up against the climb to the Perry Bar interchange. Both bore me and one is seriously over-rated in my opinion. At one all, we are stuck, veering towards a tedious stalemate.

Head Start plays as I drive down the hill. It is up against mid-table opposition from a distant IKEA and the life and optimism of the music wins through by a narrow margin to find the net. The deadlock is broken. Two-one to the boy from Blue Note!

Well into the second half and Hutcherson’s underwhelming ballad When You Are Near just does enough in defence against a distant Brownhills and motorway signs informing me of long delays through Staffordshire.

Into the last seven minutes of the match with Hutcherson holding a narrow advantage. However, the crash bang percussive avant-gardism of The Omen annoys the referee (me). Metropolitan Birmingham get a late penalty. Hilton Park Services steps up to wrong foot Hutcherson who clearly has his mind on other things.

So there you have it. The game for my attention between Bobby Hutcherson and the Bank Holiday drag along the M6 ends up in an uninspiring score draw (two all).

I will have one more go with Bobby Hutcherson when I can get hold of a fairly priced copy of The Kicker, which can be a little hard to find. In the meantime, I can’t speak too highly of Hutcherson’s contribution to Mode For Joe and he is excellent on Grant Green’s Idle Moments too. However, if you are unfamiliar with his work, he may be a better squad player than an automatic selection for your collection. He is still going strong as a performer, currently working with David Sanborn and Joey DeFrancesco and, if I’m not mistaken, may be joining them for a late summer gig at Ronnie Scott’s. If I go, it had better be incognito for fear of my flippancy being rewarded with a sharp rap on the napper with a vibes mallet. The Reid Miles cover photo and design is great, by the way.

The band etc: Bobby Hutcherson (vibraphone and marimbas); Herbie Hancock (piano); Bob Cranshaw (bass); Joe Chambers (drums). Recorded: 8 February 1966. Rudy Van Gelder Studio, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Produced: Rudy Van Gelder. Sleeve Notes: Leonard Feather. Cover photos and design: Reid Miles. Issued as Blue Note 84231.


Mode For Joe: Joe Henderson


Why should I bother with this:-  The track- Mode for Joe is wonderful.  Interesting line-up with vibes and trombone.  Amazing cover photography.  Branford Marsalis liked the album so much that he learned all of Joe Henderson’s solos by heart.  Challenging and varied; probably not recommended as an early addition to a new jazz collection- but it repays extended listening.

The band etc:- Joe Henderson (tenor sax); Lee Morgan (trumpet); Curtis Fuller (trombone); Bobby Hutcherson (vibes); Cedar Walton (piano); Ron Carter (bass); Joe Chambers(drums).  Recorded 27 January 1966.  Rudy Van Gelder Studio, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.  Sleeve Notes: Leonard Feather.  Cover photos: Francis Wolff.  Cover Design: Reid Miles.  Issued as Blue Note 4227.

The Music:-  Mode for Joe was recorded at the start of 1966 at a time of great change and dynamism, socially, politically and in jazz.  It represents Joe Henderson’s fifth and final Blue Note session as a leader in the 60’s, although he was to return with his excellent The State of The Tenor: Live at the Village Vanguard in 1985.  Written at a time when contemporaries were pushing deeply into free jazz, this one strains at the edges within clearly defined tunes.

It features an adventurous, non-standard lineup that extends to seven musicians, with vibes and trombone adding to the mix.   Some of the compositions will scare off the dinner jazz set as Henderson and Morgan veer towards free and expressive playing over complex rhythms.  Eight years earlier, Curtis Fuller had made a memorable contribution to the session which resulted in John Coltrane’s Blue Train and he is on fine form here too.

The opening track A Shade of Jade takes no prisoners with tenor sax and later trumpet delivering solos that sound like an urgent street corner dialogue of exaggerated points of view that the listener had better hear, or else!

The wonderful Mode For Joe is altogether more relaxed, a track of great beauty after an introduction to the tenor solo that verges on the sour.  Then we hear the vibes and trombone.  Pure sophistication.  I’ve Gilles Peterson (circa 1995) to thank for introducing me to this track.  Take a listen- what do you think of it?  (YouTube: courtesy of Andrew Jackson).


Black starts with a dramatic intro before heading off with a lively theme.  I probably would have sequenced this as the opening track for the album as it doesn’t frighten the horses.

Caribbean Fire Dance (YouTube: courtesy of 1blue1) has some great celebratory percussive rhythms driving things forward.  It is samba and more and a dancer could certainly make great use of it- must play it to a mate who is into salsa very soon (that’s you Pete).  Granted is straightforward hard bop while Free Wheelin’ closes the set with some delightful funk-tinged piano from Cedar Walton.


Leonard Feather provides the sleeve notes which are informative after he leaves behind his dig at Motown which was ruling the airwaves at the time.  He rejects “…the whanging guitars, adolescent lyrics and…massive accumulation of percussion” emanating from Detroit but then goes on to praise jazz alumni from Motor City, including Joe Henderson, Morgan and Curtis Fuller.  If you google Feather you will frequently find the term ‘acerbic’ in the articles you source but, because its nearly the weekend, I’m not going to be too hard on him here.

The cover:-  One of my all-time favorites.  I love the sequence of three photos of Joe Henderson: seemingly in conversation; contemplating and then taking a drag on his cigarette (sadly, Joe Henderson died of heart disease after suffering from emphysema in his final years).  Great portraiture fromFrancis Wolff though.

My copy of this album is on a CD which predates the 2003 digital remaster in the Rudy Van Gelder series, but which contains the alternative version of Black (also on the RVG collection).  CD’s of this great album cost from @£4.50 on Amazon, if you can put up with what the excellent London Jazz Collector calls ‘the evil silver disc’.  I would like a mint / near mint, vintage vinyl 1966 Blue Note first pressing-  but they seem to go for north of £90 at auction.